Battle of the Brothers
Scene: Arjuna and Karna meet in the middle of a clearing. All fighting between their respective armies has ceased.
ARJUNA- Karna, this fighting is senseless. Let us settle this battle ourselves; there is no need to endanger the lives of others in order for us to solve our own issues with each other.
KARNA- It shall be so.
The skilled warriors consulted with brahmins and other holy men on how they should proceed, and the following rules were established:
1. Celestial weapons and other boons of the gods would not be allowed.
2. Each participant would only be allowed a single weapon of their own choosing.
3. Each participant would be outfitted with the same basic armor.
4. The duel would be over when one participant either conceded or died. There would be no other way for the duel to conclude.
5. Victory in this skirmish would mean victory in the war.
6. By the powers of the gods, the terrain would change at different intervals in order to ensure that neither participant was given an advantage.
7. Violation of these guidelines in any way would anger the gods to such an extent that the individual would be condemned to never ascend to the heavens.
With the rules in place, each of the warriors drew their weapon. Arjuna, to the surprise of no man, drew his bow to do battle with his brother. Karna drew his sword. Everyone else drew a deep breath, silently praying to anyone that would listen.
A brahmin drew a circle around Arjuna and Karna, and with the clap of Krishna’s hands, the circle became a jungle.
The warriors began.
Arjuna quickly scaled a tree, firing volley after volley. Karna, moving with an almost inhuman speed, easily avoided the deadly darts and bided his time in the brush.
The circle became a desert.
Unhindered by trees and plants, Karna came charging at Arjuna with his full force, while Arjuna fired a single, solitary arrow into Karna’s shoulder. Karna felt a searing pain, but was otherwise unperturbed. When he finally reached Arjuna, he swung desperately and was able to slice off Arjuna's legs.
The circle became an ocean.
Bleeding out from his midsection, Arjuna used his arms to recover some seaweed that he proceeded to wrap around his wound in order to stem the flow of the bleeding. As he did this, he observed that Karna was drowning. Arjuna fired more arrows, albeit imprecisely due to his precarious position, and was able to hit both of Karna’s hands.
The circle became a field.
Karna, now unable to wield his sword, ran straight at Arjuna with murderous intent. Before he was able to reach him, however, Arjuna fired a few more arrows into Karna that prevented Karna from using his arms at all (Arjuna was a master of pressure points). Karna ultimately fell at Arjuna’s side, but not before kicking his arms so hard that they broke. Fully incapacitated and close to totally decapitated, both participants merely lay there until their wounds bled out and they moved on to the next life. The war was over. No one had won, but it was over. There was no celebrating, no singing; both sides had lost a valued and strong leader. The armies solemnly took the bodies and burned them with the dignity due to a ruler. There was much to do in the coming weeks, but this, this was a time for mourning.
![]() |
| Arjuna and Karna Battle Source: Flickr |
Author’s Note- After reading the 67th section of the PDE version of the story (the section involving the showdown between Karna and Arjuna), I was struck with the thought that, if it was all going to come down to these two, why would we need to have the rest of the war? Couldn’t these two just battle it out themselves? I was already frustrated when I learned about the wars that have been fought in history over a spat between two rulers or people, so this story is also me being a somewhat angsty human being who doesn't understand why people force other people to fight for them. It is in that spirit that I wrote the above story. I chose the picture above because it represents a point in the battle where either could've won... with both aiming at the other, the story is still largely unwritten (until now). I included the song that I did below both because the video is heavily influenced by Indian culture and because its melancholy melody seems to be a great "post-fight" song. The "Dog Days" of the war really are over. In the original source, Arjuna is able to slay Karna in a minute of weakness, but I love writing/reading stories where the "good guy" doesn't win in the end just because they hold the title. If art imitates life, then we should be telling stories where the person with the moral high-ground only wins some of the time.




